I will do mine similar to what Pete did on post #4.
My categories are: Location, Theme, Rooms, Dining (pools and other amenities don't matter all that much to us as 2 adult empty nesters).
I will rate a 1-5 also with 5 being best. And we have tried all but VGF. And CCV (CCV is booked for Oct).
RESORT---LOCATION---THEME---ROOMS---DINING--->TOTAL (out of 20 possible)
SSR---2---1---2---3--->8
OKW---1---2---4---2--->8
POLY---3---5---2---3--->13
BLT---4---3---4---3--->14
BRV---4---5---3---3--->15
AKV---1---5---5---5--->16
BCV---5---4---3---5--->17
BWV---5---4---4---5--->18
CCV---4---5---don't know yet (likely a 2 since you can't sleep 5 in a 1BR)---3
Rooms...We, having 3 college kids, like the 1BR villas with extra bed and/or extra bath and/or extra space. And we like BWV 1BR, even though it doesn't have these things, because it still has the jetted tub and is a home resort so we often book standard view and save points. BLT 1BR should likely be a 5 but we have only stayed in a studio and those are the smallest tightest studios so it bumps that down to a 4.
Location...We like location where we can walk or boat to a park as we are not fans of busing or monorail.
Theme...Really SSR and OKW are lacking as they seem like any condo community one might live in. And BLT is a tad sterile and average high rise hotel.
Dining...OKW has not much and the boat to DS can be problematic. SSR has a walk to DS and plenty of dining though we aren't fans of DS and our fave dining venues aren't there. BLT, BRV/CCV, Poly...you have boat or monorail to many options so that's a bit better. AKV...we LOVE all the TS venues there and love the places at AK. BWV and BCV, we enjoy some places at those resorts PLUS we can walk into Epcot for a ton more or venture to Swalphin.