Hi! I just wanted to post, that we were upgraded to Royal Palm Concierge for our Disney wedding/honeymoon trip, and it has spoiled us so much that we will ALWAYS stay RPC from now on. I have heard many reviews, positive and negative of the GF concierge, and I think that a lot of it is in your expectations. In my opinion, when you pay extra for concierge, you pay for the room location (the best in the World, in my opinion), and the services of the concierge staff itself.
Any extras, like champagne in the room, or chocolate covered strawberries, are just extras to me. I understand that they don't make an unlimited supply of each item, and it's true that the concierge lounge was pretty full when we were there. They do put different items out for each different daily offering, so if I had happened to miss something (didn't happen - fully stocked and refreshed every time we were there), I would have just waited for the next item.
I think that yes, it is a lot of money to spend, but I would be clear before I went what I was spending the money on - location & concierge services. A lot of the problems I read here, like the robe issue, could be easily remedied, and wouldn't really have put me out. I don't know that I would categorize this as a "Horror Story" - I have had many worse experiences at hotels.
To give another side of the story, they did everything possible to make our stay not only memorable, but extremely magical. From the free upgrade, to the champagne & roses, chocolates, and cards left in our room each night (different things for different nights). Perhaps our expectations were unreasonably low, but we always just go to Disney expecting things to be clean and to get what we've paid for (i.e. lagoon view room, if that's what we've reserved) and other than that, we just let Disney work their own magic, and hang on for the ride
Cheers!
Heather W