My (extended) family has always had a good time at Tony's. The food's not the best Italian food I've ever had or the best meal I've had at WDW...but it's not the worst in my own experience. I also prefer Tony's to other sit down restaurants in the Magic Kingdom for quality of food compared to price.
In fact, the one place at Disney I have no interest in returning to is another Italian restaurant, Tutto Italia in Epcot. I found that it had just ok (to bad) food...and at vastly greater prices than Tony's.
Other than that, there aren't any places I'd never go back to at Disney. Though there are a few "if I don't go there again, it's not a big deal" places.
I was underwhelmed at the lunch buffet at Tusker House in AK. I went last year with the extended family group that takes annual trips to WDW...and we went to Tusker House at my suggestion, because of the reviews I've read on disboards...we had fun with the characters, and everyone liked the food well enough, but it's not a place any of us are clamoring to go back to. It just didn't 'do it' for us.
Likewise, Coral Reef's food was disappointing. The atmosphere was good (not great), but the meal was overpriced for the quality, IMO. Nothing stood out, and for the price, I expected more.
And after two trips to Chefs de France, I can honestly say that it's another 'not a big deal if we don't go there' place for me. Food was decent, but nothing stood out. There are so many other places in Epcot that I love that if I never get back to Chefs, it's not a big deal.
However...I've learned not to take too much stock in reviews, because everyone is different. For every restaurant I don't really like that much, there are plenty of people who LOVE them. And for every place I love, there are plenty of people who would not return again ever. I still look at reviews and take them to heart when trying new places (see my going to Tusker House last year), but I also don't let reviews deter me if I'm interested in a restaurant and want to try it at least once.
In fact, the one place at Disney I have no interest in returning to is another Italian restaurant, Tutto Italia in Epcot. I found that it had just ok (to bad) food...and at vastly greater prices than Tony's.
Other than that, there aren't any places I'd never go back to at Disney. Though there are a few "if I don't go there again, it's not a big deal" places.
I was underwhelmed at the lunch buffet at Tusker House in AK. I went last year with the extended family group that takes annual trips to WDW...and we went to Tusker House at my suggestion, because of the reviews I've read on disboards...we had fun with the characters, and everyone liked the food well enough, but it's not a place any of us are clamoring to go back to. It just didn't 'do it' for us.
Likewise, Coral Reef's food was disappointing. The atmosphere was good (not great), but the meal was overpriced for the quality, IMO. Nothing stood out, and for the price, I expected more.
And after two trips to Chefs de France, I can honestly say that it's another 'not a big deal if we don't go there' place for me. Food was decent, but nothing stood out. There are so many other places in Epcot that I love that if I never get back to Chefs, it's not a big deal.
However...I've learned not to take too much stock in reviews, because everyone is different. For every restaurant I don't really like that much, there are plenty of people who LOVE them. And for every place I love, there are plenty of people who would not return again ever. I still look at reviews and take them to heart when trying new places (see my going to Tusker House last year), but I also don't let reviews deter me if I'm interested in a restaurant and want to try it at least once.