So... I was just having a thought this morning...
My hopeful plan was to make most of the MSR on my new CIC plus hopefully an Arrival Plus by paying off my car though Plastiq. Remaining balance on car is about $6300; I'm $700 into my CIC spend and have another $900 FFD on Plastiq. Suddenly I'm thinking... I should not be paying with my CIC though Plastiq, I should be buying Visa/MCGCs... right?
Scenarios:
- Make $300 payment on car with CIC, use FFDs = $300 towards car, $4.50 in URs (value $304.50)
- Make $300 payment on car with CIC, don't use FFDs = $292.68 towards car, $4.50 in URs (value $297.18)
- Buy $300 GC with CIC at office store, fee $8.95, OOP is $308.95 for
- Using FFDs: $300 towards car, $23.17 in URs (value $323.17)
- Not using FFDs: $292.68 towards car, $23.17 in URs (value $315.85)
- Buy $300 GC with CIC at office store during no fee promo, OOP is $300 for
- Using FFDs: $300 towards car, $23.17 in URs (value $323.17)
- Not using FFDs: $292.68 towards car, $23.17 in URs (value $315.85)
Did I miss anything??
You’ve got the right idea in principle. If your car loan payments through Plastiq is the “vehicle” for helping you meet MSR on the CIC, then it's better to use your CIC to buy MCGC* from office supply stores for 5x UR, then liquidate the MCGCs through Plastiq even with a 2.5% fee.
*I say MCGCs (Vanillas from drug stores, US Bank ones from office supply and grocery stores, fixed value, variable load) because I'm able to liquidate these through Plastiq. I have not had success using VGCs on Plastiq.
So, in your example:
- Make $300 payment on Plastiq towards car with CIC, 300 URs worth $4.50 in travel
- Use FFDs = $300 towards car
- Not using FFDs: $292.68 towards car
- Buy $300 MCGC with CIC at office supply store during no fee promo (Staples .com currently has $100 MCGCs with no fee, max 10) = 1,500 URs worth $22.50 in travel
- Use FFDs = $300 towards car
- Not using FFDs: $292.68 towards car
- Buy $300 MCGC with CIC at office supply store with fee (OD/OM regularly sells $200 MCGCs with a $6.95 fee and $100 MCGCs with a $5.95 fee, and often has a $10 or $15 off promo for $300 in MCGCs) = $312.90 x 5 UR = 1,565 URs worth $23.47 in travel
- Use FFDs = $300 towards car
- Not using FFDs: $292.68 towards car
I think you should jump on the current Staples .com no fee $100 MCGC offer and max that out, then apply these towards your car loan using Plastiq.
The third option I laid out does not assume any deal and does not try to optimize spend to avoid fees. For example, if you bought 1x $200 MCGC and 1x $100 MCGC, you'd be paying $12.90 in fees, which is 4.3% fees. If you bought 2x $200 MCGCs instead, you'd pay $13.90 in fees, which is 3.475% fees. With the CIC, you're earning 5x UR on the GC+fees, which you value at effectively 7.5% cash back towards travel, so you're still ahead 3.2-4% on this fee heavy transaction. If you don't use FFDs on Plastiq, the 2.5% fee is going to eat into your rewards even more. But arguably, it's still better than using the CIC to pay Plastiq directly at 1x UR to earn only 300 UR, but pay $7.32 in fees on a $300 payment.
If you've still got some time on your CIC MSR, I'd wait for the next MCGC deal at Safeway or OD/OM/Staples, and hit that hard.