Thank you.
Yes, this is all about our Jan 2018 trip. LOL! I haven't finished planning November and I am starting on Jan already. However, in my defense, it is fairly close to 180 days out for ADR's so I need to nail down dates, flights and resorts to some degree.
You make a good point about the pools. A Jan trip is a good time to stay at the CR. Plus, the idea of watching HEA from a CR balcony is definitely appealing. The fact that CR is good for a colder weather trip
is part of the reasoning.
Another part of the reasoning is that we simply enjoy the experience of staying at CR and haven't stayed there in our most recent trips to WDW. The convenience of having everything under the one roof and being able to walk to the MK are really nice features - especially with the express transportation offered these days.
The only transportation that we don't enjoy from the CR is the monorail with transfer to Epcot - but we split our stay with an Epcot resort (BWI) so we do most of Epcot and DHS when staying over there.
GF RPC has been a while as well, but our last trip was in GF SL - so while we had the GF experience, we didn't have the extra benefit of the RPC lounge. The Poly is under consideration because the last time we stayed there the Oasis pool wasn't finished and I really want to stay here with the place complete. Plus the Poly is just special somehow.
Some trips are harder to decide than others - this trip feels like I am really torn for the MK resort. AT the end of the day (tomorrow), I expect the verdict will be in, though, and I highly expect that it will be the CR!!