We have been on 3 cruises this year (January - Wish, March - Wish and September - Fantasy). We are a party of 3 and requested a private table on all three cruises with late seating dinner. We did not initially get a private table on any cruise. In January we went to Luna right away to request a private table and they were able to accommodate. In March we did the same and they were unable to accommodate so we shared with another family. On our September cruise, we were initially slated to sit with another family but it was the failed Bermuda cruise where the itinerary changed a couple days before sailing and 1500 cancelled so we ended up sitting my ourselves at a big table. I think if you have a party of 4, it’s more likely you will be accommodated since they have a lot of 4 top tables. Since we’re a party of 3, they would lose a seat by seating us alone at a 4 top. We have requested a private table again on our New Years cruise but I don’t have high hopes.