Just got back from PBH. We usually stay at HRH but decided to try PBH this trip. We really enjoyed our stay. The hotel definitely has a more relaxing atmosphere than Hard Rock. We never enjoy the loud rock music in the lobby at all times of the day, but we would still stay there if we have to.
Again, as for PBH we really liked it and we think that will be our first choice from now on. Our only real complaints about PBH are:
1) We rented a cabana and it was filthy. They didn't clean the table or chairs. They are wrought iron style so not easy to just wipe down ourselves. The lounge chair cushions felt old and dirty too. They have the lounge chair towels that stay on with a "hood," so that was nice. They should whip out a power washer each morning when they know they have a cabana reservation.
Also, the privacy panels don't stay closed. The velcro tabs are so old they don't stick. The family in the cabana next to us complained and someone came over and reattached the velcro, but as soon as they walked away the panels came apart again (it was breezy). I happened to have two large safety pins in our room so we got them and used them for the one side that separated us from them. The cabanas are very close together. The panels also seemed very old and dirty. The whole cabana felt old and dirty. But it was nice having one, just not as "nice" as we expected.
2) Mama Della's... The food was good. Nothing amazing, but pretty good for Universal. We all enjoyed our meals. The service was good, too. My only complaint is the "entertainment" while dining. We don't enjoy live entertainment that comes to your table. We find it awkward, and prefer to just enjoy our meal. I also don't appreciate the obvious waiting for a tip. We should not have to "pay" for entertainment... especially when it's so awkward. We preferred listening to them on the balcony. We really enjoyed that.
3) The shower curtain liner in our room was gross (stained and smelled mildewed). I texted their service for them to change it out when they come up to clean our room. Instead someone came up and brought it to me a few minutes later. He just handed it to me. I asked him if he expected me to change it out. I'm not sure he spoke English, which is fine, but he basically told me yes, and pointed to my bathroom. So I didn't appreciate having to remove the old one and put in the new one. (It was a new packaged one, which was nice.) I probably should have complained and asked them to do it but it all seemed pretty ridiculous. Fortunately they just snap off and on so it was simple to do. But still.
4) Not a big issue... Probably not a "complaint," but I REALLY wish they had a separate sink/vanity so we didn't have to wait for someone to be done using the bathroom to brush our teeth, get ready, etc. Doesn't work so well with four people, family or not. I did move the blow dryer and my make-up, styling products, etc to the coffee station area (moved all the coffee stuff to one side since we don't use it). I got ready there each morning. Not a big deal, but the mirror was too high for me for it to be very useful.
That's all I can think of right now. Even with those few complaints I wish I was still there right now.