I have never stayed at the cabins, but I have stayed at 10 of the other WDW resorts countless times and I will say, some stays are great and some are not so great, even at the same resort. At BWI, for example, we've had incredible stays and we've also had stays where a water main broke and they were banging around all night long trying to fix it (the carpet in the hallway was also soaked) and one where they were drilling something, literally, right into the wall behind our bed at 3 am (my DS was terrified). But . . . we go back because, typically, these things don't happen and even if they do, the resort has done something to make our trip a little brighter. If 2 out of your 10 days were bad on your last trip, but, all in all, you enjoyed your time, I would try it again. If you need a kitchen, other options, which you may enjoy, would be a 1-bedroom villa at one of the DVC resorts for which you could rent points (through a DVC dealer) or buying booking directly through WDW. We've enjoyed 1-bedrooms at CCV (located at WL), BWV, BCV and AKV. There are also 1-bedroom villas at BLT, BRV, OKW and SSR.