On one of the first sea days Dan and David came to the pool for pool games I believe. When Dan took off his shirt, knowing he was heading for the water, someone, I believe Big Mike (the guy who was volunteered for most Rockin' Bar D shows) hid the shirt from him. That night at RBD David made some mention of the shirt being held for ramson but asked that his name tag at least be returned, which I'm pretty sure it was that night.
Around the pool one day I heard the group ask one of the servers if there was anyway possible to get a photographer over so they could all take a picture with the shirt on before returning it and he came back and said they were all busy but one was with a character at the Goofy pool. The adult pool cleared as everyone in on the joke went to have the picture taken. The shirt was returned shortly after that when Mike gave it to David so that Jeff could make a joke out of it for the show that night. They again joked about it on Pub night when Dan and Luke stole Mike's shirt and had pictures taken in it.
I wanted to add I was at the pool every sea day, all day, morning until late afternoon. No I was not part of the group in question but I did speak to them and to most everyone who was around the pool daily at some point. The stories that have been circulating have been so overblown. Most days the pool was calm with people talking and getting along. On one day a couple days into the cruise there were a 3 people who jumped off the rail or the side of the hot tub into the pool, they were told not to do it again and I never saw it happen ever again. That same day there were again very few people jumping in the pool, they were told to stop and never did it again.
That same day another guest who had a pool water ball and a very small fabric football for their kids to use at the beach in the bag they were using pulled them out offering them up for a catch. I was sitting on the edge of the pool at the time and during the throwing of the balls. One man in the hot tub got the football on two occasions and winged it (he was participating, having fun, but he was over doing it) and the owner of the ball didn't like it and put the ball back in the bag. The other ball was thrown around for a long time until one person complained to security. Security came, took the ball and from then on had a presence at the pool. The people in question actually became friendly with the security and never caused problems again.
There was another day at the pool with a beach ball, the day they were given out as prizes for the MickeyH20. Security watched the entire time they bounced it around and didn't stop it so I guess there was no problem with that ball.
I never saw any flashing of body parts other than the lady in the thong. I never saw anyone who appeared to be drunk around the pool. I never found the pool noisy enough not to have read the 3 books I read while up there. Everyone seemed to be having a great time, the pool was full of life. Maybe a couple people didn't appreciate the fun being had but it appeared most people around the pool did because the pool filled, and the seats were empty, when the ball was being thrown. They didn't interfere in my vacation at all, I thought it was the best times I've ever seen around that pool. The CM's seemed to not really have a problem with these people (other than security) since the people in question at the pool were the people David told all the entertainers to pick on at RBD every night which made for some of the funniest nightime
DCL shows I remember.
This is just my opinion. As I said I was there everyday, not a participant, just an observer.