We are insured and are hoping that will cover our rental. We are Canadian and travel outside Canada has been recommended against, as well as Canadians who are currently outside the country are being told to come home. Our insurance does cover pandemics (thank goodness), so I am hoping that all we are out in this entire mess is the actual trip, but not money. We have contacted David's but have not heard back since they asked if I would like them to contact our owner.
It would have to be extraordinary circumstances for us to rent points again. A ridiculously good deal that wouldn't hurt to lose or something. We did everything right, but it is still a very complicated situation and I would love to just be able to press the "cancel" button like those with direct through Disney reservations. Unlike Disney in general where the online "complainers" are a small portion of the actual clientele, I would imagine DVC rentals skew much heavier towards having some sort of online presence in the Disney community. If not handled well, this could hit the DVC rental market hard, both on the demand and supply end.
Obviously as a renter I feel for those of us in this situation, but I feel for the owners as well, and the rental companies. I think it's safe to say nobody expected THIS kind of scenario when renting points or renting out their points.
The right thing would be for Disney to close the resorts, return points to owners and extend their use period, owners and agents like David's to return funds to renters. That way renters can then re-book their trips once we are through all this and it restarts the local economy. Disney is much better positioned and likely better insured that all us affected individuals whether owners or renters. In the meantime I applaud all the owners and renters that are working together to find the best results for all.