Do you have URs and a CSR? (I know you've got a CIP)
We booked our Christmas flights to HNL on United using URs through the CSR portal.
United has their schedule up through Christmas Day as of today, and flights out of SFO to OGG range from $299-359 per person/one way. That's really good and it'll probably creep up. I've found among the major legacy carriers, United often has the best prices to Hawaii out of the Bay Area. Hawaiian's schedule for Christmas week is just opening up and is asking $700+ per person/one way. The big question is Southwest, since it'll be a few months before they open up flights for the holidays, although I doubt the schedule change trick will be around by then. United's morning flights that'll get you into OGG earlier are, generally, pricier. But at say $359 using URs through the CSR portal, you're looking at about 24k UR per person/one way. With a CSP/CIP, that's 28,720 UR. Using United miles, it's 30.5k-37k per person/one way.