We own at BLT and VGF, so I may be a little biased:
1. VGF (studio is more than fine for a honeymoon)
Location, views, restaurants (I don’t think there’s another resort that has 3 signature restaurants), and it just feels the most luxurious. Also a spa on site that I’ve never used.
2. Poly (I’ve never stayed there, but the restaurants, location, pools and overall feel of the resort are terrific)
3. BLT (a studio would be fine for 2, but you could try to rent a 1br std for not too much more) - a theme park view would be amazing, and California Grill is one of our favorite restaurants. Between California Grill, TOTWL and possibly your room, there are the best fireworks views not in the MK.
Outside of the MK area, I’d go with BWV too. The whole Boardwalk area has great theming, and it is a bit more relaxed than the MK area.
But if all of these were available, I’d still go with VGF.
Congratulations!