Cinderella's Royal Table: It's not the best food on property, but it's okay. I'm glad we tried it, but for the price, we won't go back. It was nice eating in the castle, and we enjoyed the character interaction. I didn't like our location, but wasn't sure if it was acceptable to ask to be seated elsewhere.
Liberty Tree Tavern: Food was the best I've had in MK. We had the platter, and thoroughly enjoyed it. I wish it were a character meal.
My husband and I agree that we want to eat here again.
Be Our Guest: This location is my favorite. The food is good, but I go more for the awesome atmosphere. My family does not like it, and going is an act of love from them to me. I told them that, next time, we can just make a mid-afternoon reservation and just have cupcakes and sodas, and they found that much more palatable.
Crystal Palace: I liked CP. It didn't completely wow me, but I liked it. The family liked it. Character interaction was good; food and atmosphere were decent. We may go back, but it's not a "we gotta" like LTT is.
You didn't ask about QS locations, but I thought I would add my two cents, even if you think it's worth half that.
Columbia Harbor House: We like this one for the upper floor and it's peaceful atmosphere. Food is decent.
Pecos Bill's: Everyone says it's awesome sauce, but I didn't care for it. It was merely edible. It might be because we eat a lot of really good TexMex, but we thought it was "meh."
Cosmic Rays: My husband likes Cosmic Ray's. I though "eww" when I looked at the place, but was pleasantly surprised. Fries were crispy and burgers were good.
Gaston's Tavern: Although it has more of a snack-cart menu, we enjoyed the atmosphere and the cinnamon roll.