This particular person is happy with how the situation was handled, based on the needs of the people in their group.
What bothers me is the part of the post I am quoting here.
Members can use their points to stay at non-DVC Disney resorts. A member who is planning a trip could say to themselves, "I love the Yacht Club, and I am happy to use my points to stay in a Yacht Club room." But most members would not use their points that way, because it does not make financial sense. If a member really wants to stay at the Yacht Club, the Member can book the Yacht Club when there is a discount, and rent out their points to bring in some cash. Or bank their points into the following year. It annoys me that DVC uses this as an argument when telling telling someone that they should be happy with moving from a 1-bedroom to a hotel room.
I was looking at a fall stay for comparison. When Disney charges rack rate:
They charge $815 for a BoardWalk Villas 1 bedroom standard view for the night I was looking at.
For that same night, they charge $572 for a Yacht Club resort view room.
So it seems to me that Disney does not think that a Yacht Club room plus $50 is comparable to a BoardWalk Villas 1-bedroom.
If the Math isn't correct when Disney is taking money from people, then the Math isn't correct when Disney is moving people.
Just my take on the subject.